The Madison Fire Island Pines Hotel, Fire Island Pines

My stay was filled with highs and lows. The location right by the harbor and beach is unbeatable, making it an ideal spot for relaxation. The rooms were clean and stylish, and I appreciated the beach towels provided. However, the service was quite disappointing, especially regarding breakfast and staff attentiveness. Overall, while I loved the aesthetic and location, the lack of proper service truly impacted my experience.

I had high hopes for my stay, but the experience fell short. While the location is fantastic and the hotel has a charming ambiance, the cleanliness and maintenance of the rooms were very disappointing. The heated pool is a nice touch, and I appreciated the friendly interactions with other guests. However, the management needs to step up their game regarding cleanliness and prompt communication with guests.

I had an incredible time at The Madison Fire Island Pines! The warmth of the staff made every moment feel special, and the location was just a stone's throw from the beach. The heated pool was a fantastic bonus for late-night swims, adding to the overall charm. However, while the common areas were pristine, I could see how management could be more proactive in addressing noise issues from other guests, especially during late hours.

I had a decent stay at this hotel, with a beautiful pool area and clean rooms that added to the experience. However, it was quite pricey for the level of service I received, especially at breakfast where it felt disorganized and the staff could have been friendlier. The location is fantastic, close to the beach and local amenities, but the management needs to step up in maintaining the property and improving guest relations.

The Madison Fire Island Pines offers an idyllic getaway with its charming wood design, pristine cleanliness, and welcoming ambiance. The location is perfect, just a short walk from the beach and local hotspots. While the rooms are cozy and equipped for a comfortable stay, the absence of daily cleaning could be a downside for some. However, the attentive service and delightful breakfast options more than make up for it, ensuring a memorable vacation.